Toby Cavanaugh

And misery loves company.

It's all that matters.

Toby called Alison the night she died?

She's still in love with me.

She was very much alive.

I gave her my sweater because it was cold.

...still wearing my sweater.

Stay there, okay? Please, if you want me to listen, just stay there.

- But if you're innocent...? - Lf? You think I'm lying?

...of missing Rosewood teen Toby Cavanaugh.

I spent a year in reform school. I've got friends in all the wrong places.

...my ride's not picking me up until midnight.

If you tell your friends, you know they'll call the cops.

They've already decided I'm guilty.

I'm trying to find a way to tell you about what happened last summer.

She got me away from Jenna.

Jenna told me she'd tell people that I forced myself on her.

- But I still have so many questions. - I left my stuff behind the church.

I need to get as far away from here as I can now.

- I only came back to say goodbye. - Back from where?

No way that's the guy she's talking to in the vid.

I asked Alison to meet me so I could tell her that she did me a favor.

We didn't go anywhere. We met right outside of Spencer's barn.

If it's Toby's sweater, then he has to be the boy at the kissing rock.

She didn't want it to stop.